|
|
Smile Store - Churchill, Hitler, and "The Unnecessary War": How Britain Lost Its Empire and the West Lost the World
|
List Price: $29.95
Our Price: $19.77
Your Save: $ 10.18 ( 34% )
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Manufacturer: Crown
|
Average Customer Rating:   
|
|
Binding: Hardcover
Dewey Decimal Number: 940.5311
EAN: 9780307405159
ISBN: 030740515X
Label: Crown
Manufacturer: Crown
Number Of Items: 1
Number Of Pages: 544
Publication Date: 2008-05-27
Publisher: Crown
Release Date: 2008-05-27
Studio: Crown
|
|
|
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews:
|
Were World Wars I and II—which can now be seen as a thirty-year paroxysm of slaughter and destruction—inevitable? Were they necessary wars? Were the bloodiest and most devastating conflicts ever suffered by mankind fated by forces beyond men’s control? Or were they products of calamitous failures of judgment? In this monumental and provocative history, Patrick Buchanan makes the case that, if not for the blunders of British statesmen—Winston Churchill first among them—the horrors of two world wars and the Holocaust might have been avoided and the British Empire might never have collapsed into ruins. Half a century of murderous oppression of scores of millions under the iron boot of Communist tyranny might never have happened, and Europe’s central role in world affairs might have been sustained for many generations.
Among the British and Churchillian blunders were:
• The secret decision of a tiny cabal in the inner Cabinet in 1906 to take Britain straight to war against Germany, should she invade France
• The vengeful Treaty of Versailles that muti- lated Germany, leaving her bitter, betrayed, and receptive to the appeal of Adolf Hitler
• Britain’s capitulation, at Churchill’s urging, to American pressure to sever the Anglo- Japanese alliance, insulting and isolating Japan, pushing her onto the path of militarism and conquest
• The 1935 sanctions that drove Italy straight into the Axis with Hitler
• The greatest blunder in British history: the unsolicited war guarantee to Poland of March 1939—that guaranteed the Second World War
• Churchill’s astonishing blindness to Stalin’s true ambitions.
Certain to create controversy and spirited argument, Churchill, Hitler, and “The Unnecessary War” is a grand and bold insight into the historic failures of judgment that ended centuries of European rule and guaranteed a future no one who lived in that vanished world could ever have envisioned.
|
|
|
Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:
Summary: An Eye Opener You Really Shouldn't Miss
Comment: "All around us now we see that the west is passing away.." begins the book. Buchanan resoundingly shows that the future of disgrace and loss we now face was not foreordained, but instead caused by impetuous decisions made by British and American leadership that involved the West in an unnecessary fratricidal war. The obstruction of some legitimate territorial claims of the German peoples. The vindictive madness of Versailles. The folly of the war guarantee to Poland, the diversion of Hitler from his goal of annihilating Stalin, the loss of the captive nations behind the Iron curtain, even the roots of the Empire's entry into the Great War- all are convincingly, unanswerably laid out by Mr. Buchanan. In addition, he gives the lie to the cult of Churchill worship, which has left a costly legacy of political foolishness that persists to this day.
Customer Rating:
Summary: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
Comment: Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War by P.J.Buchanan.
Published by Crown Publishing, Hard cover 544 pages $29.95.
How to lose the largest empire the world has ever seen, in three decades.
I have the highest regard for Pat Buchanan. He is arguably the best president America never had. As a writer, he is a victim of modern technology. His prose in Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War, is closer to a blog than a literary work, and his dependence on Lexis-Nexis, is apparent on every page. That said, Buchanan is a journalist, and as a journalist he has written a short history of the world from 1914 to 1945.
If the thought of ploughing through a history book fills you with foreboding, let me assure you that Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War, is a page turner par excellence. In all the 544 pages, you will not find a wasted word or a superfluous phrase. But be warned: you must read the entire book. Buchanan is guilty of overstating his arguments for and against as the work progresses. Depending upon your particular sympathies, there are chapters that will cause you to defenestrate the book in a moment. But as you progress, your own particular point of view will be addressed.
Fundamentally, Buchanan postulates that America by design and Sir Winston Churchill as a consequence, destroyed the British Empire.
The planks of his platform are that Britain did not have to enter the war against Germany in 1914, but because they did, they escalated a German/French squabble into a world war. He essentially says the same thing about WWII.
His position is that as Kaiser Wilhelm was closely related to Queen Victoria, and wanted to be friends with Great Britain. He uses a similar argument with Fuhrer Hitler. Indeed there is a similar suggestion that Hitler respected Great Britain and went out of his way not to antagonize her.
This places Buchanan's total thesis on very thin ice. It fails to appreciate that Great Britain is an island, and as such is paranoid about hostile forces occupying the continental coast 21 miles away across the English Channel. Once a hostile power can compete with the Royal Navy, and blockade Great Britain, they are finished. Both the Kaiser and the Fuhrer were intimidated by Britain's maritime supremacy.
Of course Great Britain could have turned a blind eye to Prussian aggression, but it would have had to build up its defences and wait for a Teutonic Europe to crush arrogant little Britain. Surely it was smarter to fight them in Flanders in 1914 than the Wield of Kent in 1925?
Buchanan contends that dear old Adolf was misunderstood, and only wanted to regain the land taken from Germany at the Versailles Conference in 1919. Does Buchanan seriously believe that Britain (like America), should have stood by while Germany occupied (and destroyed), all of Europe, murdered all the Jews, and enslaved everyone east of Bratislava?
He further suggests that Great Britain's declaration of war against Germany was tantamount to suicide. And it was. Churchill knew that Great Britain could only fight for three years, and then she would be bankrupt. He also knew that someone had to have the guts to stand-up to the Nazi hordes. What he didn't expect, was that America would exploit the situation, and shake Great Britain down, and financially screw her into the ground. Roosevelt's plan was derailed when Hitler declared war on America. Had that not happened, America would have sat it out while Russia and Germany tore themselves to pieces on the Russian Steppes and our courageous Dough-Boys could have occupied what was left.
Buchanan seems to favour this Mafioso foreign policy. An analogy might be standing by as a hoodlum attacks and robs an old lady, and when they have run off, stealing her shoes.
There are occasions in life when the honorable thing to do, does not pass the Enron test of business efficiency.
It is suggested that the genesis of Britain's problems was giving up a treaty with Japan at America's insistence. Buchanan seems to think that an alliance with Britain had some kind of calming effect on the war-like tendencies of warrior nations. A Japan/Britain alliance would have gentled the Japanese condition to the extent that occupying Manchuria and China would no longer hold any attraction for them. A similar alliance with the nice old Kaiser, would have seen Germany writing loud music, and slapping their Lederhosen for the rest of the millennium.
Too much of Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War, relies on quotes from other writers to support a given thesis. These are opinions not source material. However, Buchanan comes into his own in the final chapter where the mirror of old Europe generally and Great Britain in particular is reflected on the United States of today.
Whether you are American or British, this book is tough to read - but you must read it. For, in the words of George Santayana:
"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
End
Customer Rating:
Summary: Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War
Comment: Pat Buchanan's book was long due. As a historian I am aware that is almost impossible to be objective about the two world wars that caused so much sorrow and casualties in the US. The feelings associated with WWII were too painful for somebody to be objective and to acknowledge that both sides committed crimes against mankind. We had to wait for 60 years before people have the courage to tell the story of both wars as they were. We needed historians to look at the facts and conclude that the Allies particularly England were not the nice people that most war movies want us to believe they were. Buchanan's very entertaining description of Churchill and of England plotting to destroy Germany in WWI just because of their economic might is courageous and in line with what most historians believe now. An insightful research on the vengeful Versailles treaty clearly helps us to understand why Hitler came to power in Germany in 1933. The book also points out to the other side of the coin when it mentions the Allies war crimes the carpet bombing of German and Japanese cities, the ethnic cleansing of 13 million Germans and the killing in the process of 2-3 millions of people. The Yalta conference will go into history as a shameful chapter of US and British history because of the surrendering of Eastern Europe without their consent to a dictator and in consequence much worse than Munich 1938. This book is a must read for anybody who wants to find a new refreshing look at the history of the two world wars that devastated Europe and the world and eliminated for good the British and French empires. It adds an interesting twist what if WWI had not happened.
Customer Rating:
Summary: 20th century history. A new viewpoint.
Comment: A new challenging and thoughtful review of 20th century history. All our old assumtions are questioned and lets face it that century was the worst in human history other than possibly the 14th when plague wiped out a third of the European population.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Worthwhile, but goes astray.
Comment: I think Mr. Buchanan might not have come to the conclusion that Churchill should have made peace with Hitler if he was aware of "Hitler's Second Book: The Unpublished Sequel to Mein Kampf" edited by Gerhard L. Weinberg and published in German in 1961, and in the United States in 2003.
Not to be confused with the Second Volume of "Mein Kampf" or the infamous forged "Hitler Diaries", "Hitler's Second Book" consists of the notes dictated by Hitler to his publisher Max Amann in June 1928 and kept in the safe of the Nazi publishing house until seized by the US Army in 1945.
Hitler had evidently put off publication after he realized that it gave away too much of his thinking, not only his low opinion of his political allies and intentions for the Jews, Slavs and Communists in the near future, but also the inevitability of war (allied with the British Empire) against Greater Germany's ultimate rival - the United States.
Editor Weinberg discovered the unedited manuscript in 1958 in a folder marked "Draft of Mein Kampf" while microfilming the US Army archives of confiscated Nazi files in Alexandria, Virginia prior to their repatriation. The US had transferred ownership to the Bavarian government and the Munich Institute for Contemporary History was eager to publish it, so Weinberg entered into an agreement for them to publish his annotated edition in 1961 with no one to make any profit from it.
Unfortunately in 1962 while arranging the publication of the American edition, he found a pirated edition with a bad translation of his German text was already in print, and he couldn't sue to stop them since he was not suffering any financial loss.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
